12
Charity, hope and faith
Category: UncategorizedI’ve been invited into a few charity anthologies recently. Most of them looked pretty good on paper. Like communism the equation looked sound, but once you got into the details they tended to fall apart.
One of the anthologies is in defense of a website for writers that is getting sued for, frankly, telling the truth. It happens. Probably a lot, too. Here’s the premise in this case. I and a lot of other writers are supposed to donate stories for the anthology. An editor will donate his time for the anthology. A publisher will publish the book and the monies that would have gone to the writers and the editor will go to the charity. After expenses are taken care of, naturally. But that’s cool. The expenses can’t be that high, right? I mean, we’re talking about a print-on-demand endeavor here, so a few hundred dollars for the layout, and then the public can swarm in, pay fifteen dollars a pop for the books and save the website from certain death caused by legal fees.
Of course, there’s no agenda for advertising. It’s possible that the advertising budget might have to come out of the profits for the book, too. That could slow things down. I mean, okay, so they can announce it on the internet, hit a few bulletin boards, maybe even get a banner up for free at the site they’re going to help through their legal problems. So a few more people will find out about the anthology and order it.
Right?
Sure. I’ll get right on that. After I’m done paying my bills. Oh, please don’t misunderstand me. I am rooting for the website. They’ve never done me any harm and I’m all for letting people know what companies to avoid, what “agents” are out to screw authors over and which publishers are managing to mishandle their books hard enough to make sure their authors never get paid. I’m very much all for that. I’ve never been to the site myself, but a lot of people swear by it.
I have to look at this from a business perspective, because as I’ve said before, this is my business. I’m dealing with a commodity. It may not be much as commodities go, but it’s all I have. At one point or another I’m obligated to look at what’s in it for me. For those of you who’ve grown tired of my rants, you might want to skip ahead to my closing statements. This is probably going to get ugly. First off, there’s nothing in it for me.
But wait, Jim! There’s exposure, isn’t there? It’s for a good and worthy cause and public perception will make you look like a champion of the downtrodden!
Um. No. Sorry. It doesn’t work that way. First off, there’s already something like 30-35 contributors, most of whom are tossing in stories that are under 2,000 words. My name won’t stick out in that lot. Also, I don’t tend to write short short stories. I tend to write 7-10,000 word long pieces for my promotional works, what the hell makes you think I’m even capable of a smaller piece?
Secondly, most of the people offering stories, at least according to a few of the comments I’ve seen, gave over stories that hadn’t been sold or that they hadn’t been able to sell. Nothing personal but I don’t want my stories printed with a bunch of other tales that apparently weren’t making the grade with the paying markets.
Yes, I DO sound like an ass when I say things like that, but it’s true. Because a good number of the names associated with the anthology so far are also unpublished authors. That doesn’t mean they aren’t any good, but it does mean there aren’t a whole lot of names going in there that will increase the awareness of the anthology. Get an original story by Dean Koontz, Anne Rice or Stephen King in there, and the world will know of the collection. Mortimer Pipkin, Aloysius Hammesfar and Dirk Hatrack on the other hand are not going to boost public awareness. With apologies to all three, should they happen to be fledgling authors whose names match the ones I just yanked out of the ether.
The editor is also, frankly, someone completely unknown to me. I’ve seen his name on a few boards, read an occasional post (and often disagreed with every word said editor wrote, but that’s neither here not there) and otherwise have never heard of our esteemed editor. To me that means said editor probably doesn’t have the chops to carry this off properly.
God, I hope I’m wrong and end up with egg on my face. I’d love to see the anthology kick all sorts of posterior and make money hand over fist for what I believe is a worthy cause. I’ll eat that serving of crow with gusto, boys and girls. No hesitation at all. I mean that.
So, let’s see, what else….Oh, yeah. The publisher. Print on demand. No budget for advertising, second string or volunteer layout….Yeah. Not looking any better in my eyes. Sorry, but there it is. Probably get a decent piece of clip art for the cover, unless they can convince one of the professional artists hanging on the bulletin boards to throw them a bone, or the editor’s sister is halfway decent with a pen and ink kit.
Hey, I’ve seen plenty of fly by night micro presses cranking out some truly, truly hideous covers lately and they’ve survived, haven’t they? Well, some of them, maybe? Damn. Hard to say without research and I don’t have the time to look into that, so let’s pretend a few of them are still doing well. It could happen.
So let’s do the math. 30 writers. One editor. One maybe artist. Possibly even a decent layout by someone with a clue. What the hell, we’ll call it thirty-five people minimum involved in what could be a phenomenal anthology that will pay away all the financial woes that a lawsuit has cast upon a website that helps writers by warning them about the scum waiting to prey on them in their moments of weakness or in their early naiveté.
Hell, how could I not want to step right into that project?
Oh wait. Bills to pay. Now I remember. Got a novel due. Just finished editing another novel. Been doing some freelance work as an associate editor (That means first reader, line editor and a few other hats that I have to wear in addition to writer.). Got several projects I want to get off the ground and a few collaborations I’m toying with. Still have the day job to consider, because we’ve already discussed the evils of the American medical system and how not being insured guarantees your financial destruction, haven’t we? Or is that a subject for my next essay? I can’t remember. Still have to finish a short story that I promised last October. It’s been named and half written, but I really, really need to finish it. It’s a paying market, too. I need the cash. Let’s be honest here. My short story could fill my gas tank a couple of times and it would be really, really cool to actually fill the tank for the first time in half a year. I have two novellas contracted that have to be written soon. I’ve promised a foreword to an author I admire, who for some insane reason thinks that my words at the front of his novella will help it sell. Who am I to disillusion him? That’s due next week and I haven’t finished reading the story yet. Got this essay to finish in the next fifteen minutes or I’ll be ticked at myself. No, the essay doesn’t pay, but as I’ve said before, if someone wants to believe my opinions on the writing process can be of assistance, who am I to ruin their fantasies? And if you’re reading this, you might be the someone I’m trying to help. That, or you really, really need to find new ways to amuse yourself.
I don’t have the time to give away a story for a charity anthology that will probably not sell anywhere nearly as well as I and others would like. I don’t have any spare tales floating around and I simply cannot justify losing a couple of days or more when I can barely keep up with what’s already on my plate.
I’ve got a protégé who’s been waiting patiently for me to finish reading the manuscript he sent me 6 months ago. Seriously, I feel like a worm about it, but I haven’t had the damned time.
so does skipping the charity anthology make me a bad person?
Maybe.
But it also makes me at least a little responsible to the people I already owe works to, and it makes me a little closer to being able to pay my bills.
But if I hear good things about the anthology when it comes out, and if I have the spare change, I’ll buy a copy and eventually read it. That way, when the time comes, I can lie to myself and say that I contributed to helping that website that’s always helping out the writers and stumbled into some legal problems caused by telling the truth about a few small press publishers with an attitude problem and enough money to get bitchy about it.
This comes down to the other side of professionalism. This is the part no one likes to talk about or think about. It’s a business. I would love to find the time to help out on a few charity anthologies. Show me one with an editor I admire, a publisher I respect and a few names I think will actually do some good and I’ll be there, or at least think about it while I’m catching up on my deadlines.
I don’t give free stories to webzines, I don’t accept anything below a certain amount per word when I sell stories to published magazines, I don’t sell novels to new publishers who are trying to prove their love of the genre while simultaneously not paying me. Yes, there are a few markets where I’ve broken my own rules. Yes, I’d gleefully sell a story to All Hallow’s knowing full well that there wouldn’t be a penny to be made for giving up my first print rights, because I know the exposure would be worth it.
I don’t do charity anthologies for editors I’ve never heard of or publishers that have no track record, because I can’t waste my time on them. Nothing personal. It’s business.
Pastry chefs don’t give away wedding cakes to everyone coming in off the street. They charge for their services, with exceptions for promotional reasons. I’m the same way with my stories. If there’s something in it for me, I might give away a story, but if the only thing it’s getting me is my name in print, I’ve had better offers.
Besides, the last time I did a story for free I was promised a copy of the magazine as payment and the publisher on that one screwed me. (Yeah, you know who you are. We’ve exchanged a few e-mails before you stopped responding. Can’t pay me a contributor’s copy? Don’t ask me for references….) Want to be a professional act the part. That includes deciding to say no to charities now and then. It sucks, but if you don’t follow the rules you establish for yourself, how can you expect to make a living at a job where the average writer makes less than five grand a year?
James A. Moore













